refute · session dossier · rendered from the lineage, nothing added

document renderer resource lifecycle

proposer
vendor-a/frontier-coding-agent
reviewer
vendor-b/frontier-coding-agent
convergence
converged in 3 of 8 rounds
chain verified 13 records terminal awaiting-operator head 5ccbabe473f9a12d…
round1
blocker b1 components/document-reader.tsx
Render operations can overlap on the same canvas
Rapid container resizes trigger re-renders while a prior render is still in flight on the same surface, and the renderer throws on concurrent use of one canvas
blocker b2 components/document-reader.tsx
Every page retains a full resolution pixel buffer
A long document at high device pixel ratio holds hundreds of megabytes of canvas backing memory because no page ever releases its buffer
should-fix s1 components/document-reader.tsx
Per-page failures bypass the error state
A corrupt page or a failed chunk load after the document opens leaves blank surfaces instead of the unavailable state
should-fix s2 components/document-reader.tsx
Unmount races the module import
Unmounting before the renderer module resolves lets the async body continue and create a loading task that no cleanup owns
nit n1 components/document-reader.tsx
Backing store and style sizes round independently
Fractional widths floor twice and drift the backing store off the styled size by a pixel, softening glyph edges
open after round: b1 b2 s1 s2 n1
repair
Rewrote the renderer around windowed rendering. Only pages near the viewport hold pixels and pages leaving the window release their buffers. Render tasks are tracked per page and cancelled before reuse. The whole async path reports into the error state and cancellation is checked after every await. Sizes round once from a shared css width.
sha256:6f1f3a2b9c8d47e5a0b1c2d3e4f5061728394a5b6c7d8e9f0a1b2c3d4e5f6a7b
round2
b1 fixed · b2 fixed · s1 fixed · s2 fixed · n1 fixed
blocker b3 components/document-reader.tsx
Cancelled render cleanup can drop a newer task from the tracking map
A page leaves the render window and re-enters before its cancelled task settles, the settling cleanup deletes the map entry unconditionally, and the newer task loses tracking so a later cancel misses it
open after round: b3
repair
Cleanup now removes a task from the tracking map only when the map still holds that exact task. Freeing a page cancels but leaves the entry until its promise settles, so a re-entering page waits out the old task.
sha256:9a8b7c6d5e4f30211203f4e5d6c7b8a9908172635445362718095a4b3c2d1e0f
round3
b3 fixed
nothing survives this round

Deterministic gates — agents argue, gates decide

pass build

Terminal


Awaiting operatorthe session cannot merge anything. approval belongs to a human.